The Deep Dive

How to build a community

Five research-backed lessons for turning an audience into a community.

Most brands have followers. A few have communities: people who interact with each other, not only with the brand. Decades of marketing research, plus a few brands doing it well, point to five moves that make the difference.

📚 Grounded in 5 peer-reviewed studies 🏷 4 brand examples ⏱ ~8 min

This is the deep-dive chapter of our Learning Bite. The bird's-eye overview of social media lives on its own page; here we focus on one question: how are communities actually built?

Follow the path
🔮
Lesson 1

Lead with a belief, not a product

People commit to a community for meaning, not features. Decide what the brand actually stands for before building any channel, because the shared belief is what members gather around.

Without it, you have an audience that watches. With it, you have people who identify with the brand and with each other.

Muniz & O'Guinn (2001) call this shared consciousness: a felt sense of "we" that defines a real community.
Oatly brand imagery Ep. 1
OatlyOatly
How Oatly does it. It never really sold oat milk. It sold a cheeky, planet-first worldview and let people wear it like a badge. See how ↗
🌱
Lesson 2

Start with a small, active core

Communities grow out of a dense core, not a large audience. Instead of buying reach, recruit a handful of people who already care and give them a real role in shaping the space.

Thirty active members set the norms and conversations that thousands of passive followers never will.

The principle is density of engagement over headcount: seed the community deliberately before trying to scale it.
HOLY founders Ep. 2
HOLYHOLY
How HOLY does it. Three Berlin students seeded "The HOLY Squad," giving creators free product with no strings. The believers did the rest. See how ↗
🏛️
Lesson 3

Give members a place and an identity

A community needs a home and a shared identity: one platform to gather on, plus rituals, shared language, and recurring events. These turn individual customers into members who feel part of something.

When someone can say "I'm one of us," you have an identity, not just an account.

Rituals and traditions (Muniz & O'Guinn, 2001) and shared brand experiences (McAlexander et al., 2002) are what bind members together.
Salesforce Trailblazer community Ep. 3
SalesforceSalesforce
How Salesforce does it. It turned users into "Trailblazers," gave them the "Ohana" family language, badges to earn, and events to gather at. See how ↗
📣
Lesson 4

Let members create the value

In strong communities, members produce much of the value themselves: answering each other's questions, recommending the brand, and making content no one asked them to. The brand's role is to enable and recognise this, not to control it.

When members teach each other and advocate on their own, marketing shifts from something you do to something the community does with you.

Schau, Muñiz & Arnould (2009) show value is co-created through member practices like welcoming, advocating, and helping.
Gong brand imagery Ep. 4
GongGong
How Gong does it. Instead of ads, it turned its own employees and fans into a daily chorus on LinkedIn, educating, never selling. The crowd became the channel. See how ↗
🕊️
Lesson 5

Keep belonging voluntary

Strong identification with a community drives engagement, but it has a limit. When members feel pressured to conform or participate, that pressure can push them away rather than draw them in.

The healthiest communities let members choose their own level of involvement, so they stay because they want to, not because they feel they must.

Algesheimer, Dholakia & Herrmann (2005) find that normative community pressure can trigger reactance, so belonging must remain voluntary.
The takeaway

Don't build an audience that watches you. Build a community that talks to each other.

Supplementary reading